THE COLONEL HENRY RYERSON
                           CIVIL WAR ROUND TABLE

                Jennifer C.S. Brylinski, President and Newsletter Author

                      March 16, 2010, Meeting Program Highlights:


                       
 The Great Shohola POW Train Wreck

Just picture that hot July afternoon in 1864 up along the Delaware River between
New York and Pennsylvania…  An Erie railroad locomotive pulling 17 cars and
carrying over 800 Confederate prisoners is on its way north to Elmira Prison.  And it’s
going to meet its fate when a coal train with 50 loaded cars starts barreling its way
south along the same tracks!  

Come and hear our March speaker, John Punola, talk about that frightful day.   What
makes the talk especially poignant for us is that the train wreck site and casualty
burial locations are located only about 40 miles north of Newton, NJ, along the
Delaware River and is an easy drive for those who want to visit the location of a real
Civil War tragedy.

John Punola is a nationally known outdoor writer, book author, public speaker, and
fisherman.  He has made many appearances on national television and his specialty
is fishing for shad and smallmouth bass.  But it’s not all fishing with John; he also has
a keen eye for history, and has authored some good historical articles.  We know
you are going to enjoy his presentation about the Civil War Disaster at Shohola.

Upcoming Civil War Round Table Events:

April 20, 2010 – Rhonda Florian – The Lives of Southern Women
May 18, 2010 – Annual Dinner Meeting, Lafayette House (6 – 9 PM)
May 22, 2010 – Spring Tour – An Overview at the Antietam Battlefield


The Colonel Henry Ryerson Civil War Round Table provides educational programs,
tours, and fellowship for individuals interested in the Civil War Era.  Meetings are free
and open to the public.  For more information please call Jennifer at 845-295-2603
during work hours, or check out the Round Table’s website at    www.ryersoncwrt.
com


       MEETING DATE:  Tuesday, March 16, 2010, At 7:30 PM
    Sussex County Community College, Newton, NJ, in the Theatre (D-Building).
  
           THE EXCHANGE AND PAROLE SYSTEM DURING THE CIVIL WAR

Before 1861, Americans never had to face the problem of handling large numbers
of captured enemy soldiers. The Civil War abruptly changed that situation.

In the beginning of the War, prisoners of war were exchanged right on the
battlefield (private for a private, captain for a captain, etc.). Soon this system broke
down and prisoners were brought to large "holding pens" on either side to wait for
exchange or parole. In this system, after the exchange occurred, if one side still
had prisoners left, those excess prisoners would be released on parole. Paroled
prisoners were returned to their side, but were prohibited by an oath of honor from
taking up arms until they were properly exchanged. Generally, each side maintained
its own parole camps where their paroled soldiers were kept while they awaited
exchange. In some cases the parolee was allowed to return home until exchanged.

But even that system eventually had problems because many of the prisoners after
being paroled would just immediately return to their military unit. In August of 1864,
General U.S. Grant ended all exchanges of prisoners, an action militarily sound but
with disastrous results for both Union and Confederate prisoners. The "holding
pens" now became permanent prisons, most of which had no ability to handle the
number of prisoners that would be sent to them.
Neither side knew how to address the problem and neither made a concerted effort
to do so. In place of badly needed attention there was inexperience, clumsiness,
and indifference. Suffering and neglect of prisoners of war were present in both
Union and Confederacy prisons. The prisons lacked resources, had inadequate
facilities, overcrowded conditions, and were usually manned by second-rate
officials.

The two most infamous Civil War compounds went into operation in 1864. The
South's Andersonville prison (officially known as Camp Sumter, Georgia) was the
largest of all. It began receiving inmates before construction was completed. Some
52,300 Federal enlisted men were sent there; more than 13,200 perished from
disease, exposure, and lack of medicines, giving it a death rate of around 28%.

In the North, at a prison camp for Confederates at Elmira, New York, such
scourges as diarrhea and pneumonia killed almost one-fourth of the captured
soldiers (of 12,123 inmates, 2,963 died) over the course of the prison's twelve-
month existence. The Federal prison at Rock Island inIllinois had a death rate of
about 17%, and Fort Delaware south of Philadelphia had a death rate of about 13%.

During and especially after the Civil War, each side pointed fingers of guilt at the
other. Henry Wirz, commandant at Andersonville Prison, on charges of conspiracy
and murder, was the only Confederate official to be tried and convicted of war
crimes resulting from the Civil War. Perhaps no aspect of the bitter Civil War has
triggered more accusations, more vehement passions, and more unresolved
controversy than the mistreatment of captured Federal and Confederate troops
held in prison camps.